Versionen im Vergleich

Alte Version 8

changes.mady.by.user Peter Kochmann

Gespeichert am

verglichen mit

Neue Version 9

changes.mady.by.user Peter Kochmann

Gespeichert am

Schlüssel

  • Diese Zeile wurde hinzugefügt.
  • Diese Zeile wurde entfernt.
  • Formatierung wurde geändert.

...

ATS (e.g. download-atom)Test (e.g. A.01.TGR1)Type of commentSeverity (minor, medium, critical)CommentsProposed changeResolutionKommentiert von (nur zur internen Verwendung)
 Download Service (Atom) A.15 CR criticalThe Attribute: type="application/Atom+xml" is required. If this Attribute is part of the link-tag the link does not work in the Internet Explorer! The examples for INSPIRE-Atom-Feed contain the type-Attribute in the link-tag, too. And also it does not work in IE. That not the sense of interoperability. If the type-Attribute will delete the link work in the IE.    Cancel the test Attribute type in the link-tag and Change the requirement.  Dombert (GDI-LSA)
Metadata (discovery)A.05.IR14.ds.keywordCTmediumWhat happens if there's no descritiveKeywords block citing INSPIRE GEMET at all? I understand the current description of the test as follows: the test will work for each block and will skip to the next block (without failing) if no reference to INSPIRE GEMET is given. It's allowed to have additional descriptiveKeyword blocks citing nothing or other concepts."If at least one descriptiveKeywords block references INSPIRE GEMET or any duplicate (...) and at least one keyword from that source is found in this block, the test succeeds, otherwise it will fail." Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (discovery)A.17.IR22.IR23.ds.temporalEDminormissing word at first bullet at "Test method""Is a valid TimePeriod given and ..." Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (discovery)A.17.IR22.IR23.ds.temporalCTmedium

I think it has to be the other way round: The test regarding TG Req. 23 will be passed only if at least one of the three date-checks is valid.

Otherwise (as I read the documented tests by now) the test could fail e.g. because of a missing revision date though there is a valid creation date.

"The test will fail be passed if and only if at least one check among date of publication, date of last revision or date of creation doesn’t evaluates to true." Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (discovery)

A.19.IR28.ds.conformity

A.20.IR29.ds.specification

GE / CTcriticalTG Requirement 28 demands a conformity statement regarding a certain specification: IR interoperability (1089/2010 and amendments). This has not been considered in these tests. A test method aiming at the particular content of element specification is necessary.improve A.19.IR28.ds.conformity concerning this issue Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (discovery)A.20.IR29.ds.specificationGE / CTmediumTG Requirement 29 demands the conformity statement to be formed as DQ_DomainConsistency. This has not been considered in this test.improve A.20.IR29.ds.specification concerning this issue Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (discovery)A.26.IR38.md.contact.roleEDminorredundant and missing word at first bullet at "Open questions""Is The the codeList URL ..." Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (interoperability)<all>GEminor

All regulations on "Metadata for interoperability" (see following issues) aim at datasets and series and only when applying to IR 1089/2010.

How to define that? Conformity statement citing IR 1089/2010 with pass= TRUE?

Or are these regulations relevant for all INSPIRE metadata regardless the level of fulfilling IR 1089/2010?

? Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (interoperability)A.1 Coordinate Reference SystemGEmedium

Coordinate Reference System is one of the mandatory elements in "Metadata for interoperability" for datasets and series.

There should be at least a test on pure existence for datasets and series if the resource is already in focus of IR 1089/2010.

 Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (interoperability)A.3 EncodingGEmediumEncoding is one of the mandatory elements in "Metadata for interoperability" for datasets and series.There should be at least a test on pure existence for datasets and series if the resource is already in focus of IR 1089/2010. Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)
Metadata (interoperability)A.5 Character EncodingGEmediumCharacter Encoding is one of the mandatory elements in "Metadata for interoperability" for datasets and series.There should be at least a test on pure existence for datasets and series if the resource is already in focus of IR 1089/2010. Peter Kochmann (GDI-NW)